NEWBERRY – A 22-year-old Newberry man was arrested early Saturday and charged with attempted homicide after a woman was allegedly beaten inside a Newberry apartment, according to the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office.
Deputies responded at 2:16 a.m. Saturday, Dec. 20, 2025, to the Vanguard Apartments, where a deputy reported hearing a faint cry for help while checking the area. Moments later, the victim ran from an apartment yelling for assistance before collapsing on the ground, the arrest report states.
The deputy reported that the woman was actively bleeding from her head, covered in blood and limping. She had extensive bruising and scratches and said she had been in and out of consciousness.
Inside the apartment, deputies reported finding Jayce Benjamin Timmons standing in the hallway with blood on his pants and shoes but no obvious injuries.
According to the report, the victim said Timmons punched her earlier in the night at a restaurant. She returned home without him, but he later followed her and entered the apartment using a key he had taken without her consent. The victim said Timmons took her car key and snapped it, preventing her from leaving.
The victim told deputies that after an argument, Timmons began striking her with his closed fist and kicking her. She reported that he said he did not care if she died and later told her he was going to kill her.
She said the assault stopped when a deputy rang the doorbell, at which point Timmons allegedly said, “Oh, look, they came to save you; now I’m going to go to prison.” The victim told deputies she believed Timmons intended to kill her and would have succeeded had law enforcement not arrived. She said she scratched him so he could be identified if he killed her.
After being advised of his Miranda rights, Timmons reportedly told deputies the victim was “acting crazy” when he arrived at the apartment. He said he did not know where the blood on his pants and shoes came from or how the victim and apartment became covered in blood. Deputies observed blood on Timmons’ hands and knuckles and scratches on his face and throat.
Timmons was charged with attempted homicide, committing a felony that could lead to death, hindering a victim’s communication with law enforcement, false imprisonment and misdemeanor property damage for breaking the car key.
His full criminal history was not immediately available, but records indicate he is on pretrial release for a hit-and-run crash in Hillsborough County and faces an Alachua County charge of driving without a valid license. A sworn complaint for domestic battery was filed against him in September 2025 but was later dropped.
Judge Julie Johnson ordered Timmons held without bail pending a hearing on a motion from the State Attorney’s Office seeking to keep him jailed without bail until trial. If the motion is denied, bail will be set at that hearing.
# # #
Email cwalker@
alachuatoday.com